Mid-level Member

|
|
| |
| Posts: 605 | Location: Calgary Alberta | Registered: August 01, 2004 |    |
|
Moderator i-Supra Journeyman
|
short throw shifters suck. dont miss a gear! i'd stick with the SOGI hack job. i love it. i've driven cars w/ short shifters and hated them. they're good for anything but aggressive driving. its too easy to miss a gear. -shaeff
|
| |
| Posts: 3068 | Location: Upstate NY | Registered: April 02, 2003 |    |
|
Mid-level Member
|
Now your saying the complete opposite of what I've heard about the real short shifters compared to the sogi mod. Which one is it is it good or does it just suck and is a complete waste of money?
"Children children settle down! put down the hater-ade and lay off the carnation cream-o-bit*h."
|
| |
| Posts: 219 | Location: Las Vegas, Nevada, U.S. | Registered: August 31, 2003 |    |
|
Senior Member

|
Give me a couple months and I'll tell you.. I will be buying a short shifter for my R154. Let's face it: I can't afford a V160 getrag for my swap, and I probably won't do one for a couple years after, if at all.. so it's R154 for me, and with the R154 or W58, I need less shift throw/travel.
Actually, I want a short shifter because for my purpose, with the 2JZ swap, the 1JZ bellhousing is supposed to be shorter than the 7M's, so when it is equipped on a 2JZ the shifter is supposed to sit a LITTLE bit further forward [or so Arnout has told me] and spacers on the tranny or a short shifter helps this.. otherwise the shifter will sit too far forward. Personally, I like the SOGI hack job, but I would rather have something to actually reduce the throw than just shortening the length and not changing anything having to do with the fulcrum point. I would think that there would be more missed with the SOGI mod than there would be with a REAL short shifter.. because with a real short shifter, you are not only reducing the throw [less travel than you are used to, so if you shift like normal, you are actually putting the shifter where it needs to be with less effort than it would take with a stock shifter], but you are also replacing the stock bushing, which has a tendency to screw up your shifts as well. This is recommended to be installed with some white lithium grease and "broken in", but I've heard that the results are great.
|
| |
| Posts: 2245 | Location: Yuma, AZ | Registered: September 22, 2002 |    |
|
Moderator i-Supra Journeyman
|
in medic's case, i can see the use of a short throw shifter, but (and this is my opinion of course) i hate them. when driving aggressively you're more likely to miss a shift, whereas with the SOGI job, the throw is still the same, and if you just replace the bushing, it feels like a world of difference. everyone has different opinions. get one, if you like it, then great! if not, sell it to someone, i'm sure somebody will buy it if you cut the price a little. i've driven numerous cars with short throws shifters, and when i was romping on them, well, lets just say it sucked. even DR. jonez hates them, if i recall correctly. if you get one, post a reveiw back here on it! -shaeff
|
| |
| Posts: 3068 | Location: Upstate NY | Registered: April 02, 2003 |    |
|
Moderator i-Supra Journeyman
|
heh, yeah i forgot to mention that i cut the stick down, shaved it down (in order to make it the same thickness) then re-threaded it for the stock knob. looks/works great! -shaeff
|
| |
| Posts: 3068 | Location: Upstate NY | Registered: April 02, 2003 |    |
|
Mid-level Member
|
I went to this sogi.com and i Found it to be entirely worthless. It's in some other language and doesnt appear to have anything to do with cars. Second...is it just me or does the stock shifter on the mk3 look like you could play baseball with it? Mine is a monster. I went to suprasport.com. Is that the only short shifter out for our cars? That would be hard to believe considering how rediculously large the stock one is. I'm not talking about just the knob. The shifter itself is taller than golly green himself. I've got a 1990 non turbo awaiting gte swap. Help me out guys... Thanks
Ryan 2nd 1990 Supra. Awaiting 1jz-gte 02' Sentra SE-R Spec V - Sold First mk3 was sold 3-8-03.
|
| |
| Posts: 180 | Location: Arizona | Registered: November 21, 2002 |    |
|